"Eye-rolling comic foil"

“As the leading church lady, Cindy Sadler made an eye-rolling comic foil.”
— Michael Barnes

"Comically maternal in manner and tone"

“Cindy Sadler was comically maternal in manner and tone as Elvira’s confidante, Zulma.”
— Scott Cantrell

"Plush voice"

“Zulma was portrayed with determination and plush voice by mezzo-soprano Cindy Sadler.”
— Erik Eriksson

"Dark and effective voice"

“Cindy Sadler, in her role as Zulma, Elvira’s personal slave, displayed a dark and effective voice and handled herself well onstage.”
— Terence O'Grady

"Perfect marriage of acting and vocal expression"

“In particular, mezzo-soprano Cindy Sadler forged the perfect marriage of acting and vocal expression to vitalize Katisha. Her true mezzo-soprano voice was absolutely present on the Act I finale, when she vowed vengeance against Nanki-Poo. And, at that point in every good comedy when the stereotype falls away and the character has a deep, sincere moment, Sadler beautifully conveyed Katisha’s despair on the second act aria, ‘Alone and Yet Alive’.”
— James O. Welsch

"Commanded the role"

“Cindy Sadler commanded the role of the revengeful, ‘sufficiently decayed’ daughter-in-law elect Katisha.”
— Debra A. Moroff

"First-rate singing... dignifies the role"

“..first-rate singing … Cindy Sadler dignifies the role of Bloody Mary with some lovely singing.”
— Bob Nesti

"Transcends opera... well-acted, down-to-earth"

“William Thorpe and Cindy Sadler have experience that transcends opera, and it showed in their well-acted, down-to-earth Luther Billis and Bloody Mary.”
— Jeffrey Ganz

"Great depth and warmth"

“As the servant, Suzuki, mezzo-soprano Cindy Sadler sang with great depth and warmth.”
— Mike Greenberg

"Touchingly helps build the emotional house of cards"

“Sadler’s protective affection touchingly helps build the emotional house of cards that is the Act II Flower Duet.”
— Jerry Young

"Affecting portrayal"

“The cost of the tragedy was best measured in Cindy Sadler’s affecting portrayal of Turiddu’s mother.”
— Jerry Young

"Lush contralto"

“The Queen’s ladies … sing stylishly, especially Sadler’s lush contralto.”
— Orange County Register

"Rightfully comic and fine-voiced"

“… rightfully comic and fine-voiced …”
— Robert C. Fuller

"Charmingly good and funny"

“Cindy Sadler was a charmingly good and funny Martha Schwerlein who delights as she matches wits with the devil.”
— Weekly Register Call

"Has the timing... chuckles"

“Cindy Sadler’s Martha Schwerlein has the timing of one who knows how to extract a few chuckles from the audience.”
— Kay Turnbaugh

"Grace, charm, and a great deal of gusto"

“Cindy Sadler carries off the considerable character of sweet little Buttercup with grace, charm, and a great deal of gusto —- not to mention a genuinely gorgeous voice.”
— Rachel Jenkins

"Gorgeously lush"

“Cindy Sadler’s mezzo-soprano was gorgeously lush throughout the range…”
— Duncan Goodrich

"Rich low notes and smooth phrasing"

“Mezzo-soprano Cindy Sadler brought rich low notes and smooth phrasing to what is a less than flashy part.”
— David Mead

"Velutinous-sounding mezzo... most dramatic scene"

“…the soloists stole the show. Velutinous-sounding mezzo Cindy Sadler pulled off the most dramatic scene as Amneris from Aida.”
— Michael Barnes